
“GUILTY” is j-pop diva Ayumi Hamasaki’s 9th studio album . It’s official release date was January 1, 2008, but it actually hit the stores 2 weeks before that date. Selling over 400,000 copies its first two weeks, it reached #2 on the Oricon charts, which caused a lot of controversy throughout her fandom, because Ayu lost her #1 streak. It’s a shame to see how many of her fans actually cared more about her sales rather than the album itself.
Anyways. The albums was released in 2 versions: a CD+DVD version and a CD only version. Both versions had different covers (as expected) and they received mixed reviews. One the one hand, they were refreshing thanks to the background. The dress was gorgeous and the nails were fucking awesome. On the other hand, they didn’t fit the album at all. I wanted to see an Ayu suffering and actually feeling guilty. Plus, there’s something weird about her face. I’m getting a little bit tired of her I’m-ready-to-suck-you face.
As for the album itself, it received some mixed reviews as well, but well, we don’t give a fuck about them, right? Our review pwns all those craptacular reviews, so here we go:
1. Mirror
WOW. This intro is amazing. It starts with a modem sound and just when it’s finished, we can hear some drums which make me think of some soldiers marching. Then we can hear Ayumi who starts with a soft, yet defiant voice. Hard guitars start playing and we’re finally at the most powerful part of the song. I can’t describe how good this part is. It’s ausawm. Then the song slows down and ends in a sweet, mysterious way.
This intro definitely gets you in the mood for GUILTY, and, along with Not yet, is the best album opening.
2. (don’t) Leave me alone
Let me tell you something: this song rocks. Ayumi radiates attitude. When I first listened to this song, I felt somehow disappointed. I thought it was kinda monotonous and the chorus didn’t feel like a chorus to me. But now I’ve definitely come to like it. It’s powerful and it’s a great song when you’re feeling angry. And for the record, this song was actually really successful in Japan. It should’ve been released as a single or something. 10 points for bad-ass Ayu.
3. talkin’ 2 myself
Arguably the album most rockish song, and definitely one the rockiest in her entire career. There are hard guitars (again) playing all the time, and Ayu’s vocals are deep and mysterious, which makes this song dark as hell. I’m tired of using this word, but the song is powerful. When the single came out I overplayed this song, so I rarely listen to it anymore, but it’s definitely worth it.
4. decision
These 2 songs (t2m and decision) shouldn’t be together. They didn’t work out as a single and the don’t really work out together in the album. Why? Simple. Talkin’ 2 myself tends to overshadow decision, which is also a great song.
It starts softly, which makes you think you’re just about to listen to a ballad or something alike, but with a sudden BAM! we’re dragged in a rock song. I don’t know if it’s the music, or Ayumi’s vocals, but I consider this song even more powerful than t2m. The ending is superb, with her already signature “woo yeah’s”, which are an exquisite orgasm.
5. GUILTY
Disappointing. Not as bad some people say, but still disappointing. I guess Ayumi wanted to make a really dark song, but it end up being quite boring. It never comes to a real climax. There’s nothing that could take your breathe away in this song. I expected more from it, since it’s the album’s title. It does, however, serve as the perfect transition between decision and fated. Even the lyrics can be somehow related. In decision she was the bad ass Ayu who can choose whatever she wants. In GUILTY she wonders if she has made the right choices, while in fated we finally see how she regrets the decision she made.
6. fated
Released as a b-side of the summer single “glitter”, fated has been quite a controversial song. It came out when Ayumi announced her break-up with the actor and singer Nagase Tomoya, who had been her boyfriend for almost 7 years (holy shit). Since the song kinda talks about a break-up, we could assume she’s talking about him.
As for the song…it’s depressing from start to end. It’s a slow rockish ballad which most people consider to be lame. I don’t. The music is beautiful, and she sings it in such a special way. You can feel her sadness in her voice. Maybe it could’ve been a little bit more powerful. Just like in GUILTY, there isn’t a breath-taking climax, which is why most people didn’t like this song.
As an album track, it’s such a nice break from the “hard-rock” songs, and it’s followed by another master-piece, which is:
7. Together When…
Oh my God. This song is so fucking sad. If you weren’t sure if she was talking about Tomoya in fated, now you can totally be certain. This song is beautiful in every single aspect. The music is beautiful and touching. Her vocals are painfully gorgeous, while the lyrics are totally heartbreaking. The first time I read/listen to it, I broke down in tears, and I still do it sometimes (I’m an emotional bitch <3). The ending of this song is epic. The way she sings the last two choruses is fabulous. It makes me shiver.
Nobody should miss this song. It’s already became an Ayu classic.
8. Marionette -prelude-
OK. Wow. This interlude is absolutely terrifying, like it’s something that I wouldn’t listen to alone in a dark room. It begins with these creepy sounding chimes and then an even more scary instrumentation. At certain parts you can hear an old grandfather clock chiming or even at one part, the entire song stops and you can hear a music box being wound up. The interlude really gives the listener the creepy feeling of being in a haunted house or in some place where you don‘t belong and feel as though something is following you. It gives off an empty and really malevolent atmosphere, but towards the end, the music gets higher and happier and then leads right into the next tune.
9. Marionette
Like the song before it, this one begins pretty scarily also, with a gorgeous arrangement of a piano, music box sounds and haunting strings. Soon after it begins, Ayumi comes in with her deep, throaty voice singing the verses slowly and melancholic. It really gives the song that sorrowful feel, everything just works together to sends out that feeling. Then when the chorus comes in, the music speeds up and bit and Ayumi’s singing becomes louder, giving off a much more powerful and strong vibe than the sorrowful verses. It’s really stunning. It’s totally one of my favorite tracks on GUILTY, I have nothing bad to say about it.
10. The Judgement Day
When you hear the title what would you expect? A dark rock song or something right? But no, we get some bizarre poppy dance interlude. WTF. Throughout the whole song she sing “la la la” which really bugs me, since she says that in nearly every song anyways. What makes her think I want to hear it through an entire interlude? Although it begins slow with a creepy organ in the background, it soon picks up to the poppy dance tune that I mentioned before. This is like the happiest Judgement Day ever, WTF Ayumi. </3
11. glitter
The following song is the very first single ayu released for the GUILTY album, glitter. The song begins with the chorus, which is really different, but soon breaks into an uplifting twinkling instrumentation. Now this is a perfect summer song, not the crap that we reviewed previously. Throughout the verses, we get a sprinkling of some QT Engrish like “Yes, cuz believe in love~”, which just add to the happy summer feeling. The verses are much more laidback, but the choruses are definitely the part that shine in the song. The lyrics, the singing, the music all work so amazingly in the chorus to just lift up your spirits and make you want to dance. It’s an awesome summer song and even after a year, I love it to death.
12. MY ALL
We get another upbeat track with the next song, MY ALL. A lot of people compare it to “Replace” from MY STORY, but I don’t really hear it. Maybe it’s because a lot of ayu songs tend to sound alike, I’m not sure. Anyways, the song begins with a really happy guitar solo and some poppy synth laid in the background, it instantly sets the feeling of the song to follow. The verses are song really quickly but really mellow, which is completely different than the way the happy lyrics of the chorus are sung. The chorus gives the listener a really happy uplifting feeling, I love it so much. I used to hate this song because I thought it was kind of boring and repetitive, but I’ve definitely learned to love it. It’s a song that’ll keep your spirits up, fer shurr.
13. reBiRTH
Ugh – another interlude. This is the third one I’ve reviewed so far. It’s yet another ayu interlude that’s really spacey and bizarre, it’s kind of like LABYRINTH on her last album, Secret. I’m not sure what else I can say about it but that’s it’s really out there … so yeah….
14. untitled ~for her~
I know that everyone loves this song since it’s for ayu’s dead friend or whatever, but I personally find this song disgustingly boring. Sure it’s a nice gesture or whatever, but did she have to make it so yawn inducing? But don’t get me wrong, I love the emotion that ayu puts into this song, you can tell it’s really a heartfelt number. Her voice goes really well against the pretty synth in the music, but that’s about it that I loved. The person she wrote it for was very close to her so it must’ve hurt to lose her and I’m glad that she showed her love this way, even if I REALLY don’t like the song. The choruses aren’t really stand out when a song’s chorus should really stick in your mind and the verses are even more forgettable, I just don’t like this song at all. It’s a long and boring way to finish off a pretty good album.
Nacho’s Conclusion:
GUILTY is an underrated album which deserved both better sales and better reviews. It’s definitely not her best album so far, cause it feels kinda rushed (*cough*4 interludes*cough*). I think she should stop releasing an album each year. That way she would have some extra time, and she’d only release when she feels she’s ready.
About the PV’s, they’re definitely not her best either, but some of them are pretty interesting (Together When…, Marionette, and the so fucking hated “mini movie” (mini movie my balls) Distance Love. For God’s sake, we can finally see Ayu kissing a guy! Enjoy it, bitches!
Overall, the album’s really good, and it shows a much mature Ayumi than in her previous albums. I’ll give it an 8.5 cause there are way too many interludes, but, if you don’t care about them, then imagine it’s a 9 lol.
Score: 8.5/10
Kaori’s Conclusion:
Hm, what’s one word that I can use to sum up GUILTY? Different. This album was a really dark album with lots of rock tunes and deep lyrics, I think that surprised a lot of her fans, especially me. You usually expect some rock songs and then a handful of pop songs on an ayu album, but this one was different. It’s not as bad as people say, but it’s totally not her best effort. There’s so much I could whine about, like it could’ve been longer, it could’ve been less rock, it could’ve cut out “untitled ~for her~” but WTF does complaining do? In the end I enjoyed it, but not as much as I usually enjoy an ayu album.
Score: 7.5/10